Baba
Sometimes people wonder why some of our Ananda Marga books are authored under the name Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar whereas other books are signed as Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji. For years, people have been going back and forth about this, even questioning if these are two personalities or one.
Some want to know if both of these names refer to the same Divine Entity Baba. Here are some points related with this issue.
Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar & Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji: one & the same
Look at it this way, Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar and Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji certainly refer to one singular Entity.
For example, in the mundane sphere it is just like the situation of my mother. I call her mother; my sons and daughters call her grandmother or grandma; my cousin calls her aunty; and my father calls her Prama. And furthermore when she was working in the office she had her official designation also. Her colleagues were calling her yet a different name. In this manner, a single personality, my mother, has so many names - according to her relationship with a given person. So those names, i.e. mom, Prama, aunty, and grandma etc, do not refer to different personalities. Rather, she is one personality who has multiple names that apply to her various roles in life.
And verily this is the case with most people. According to particular situations they have a given name, yet all along they are the same person and personality.
Multiple names - one person
The following graphic example is moving in this same direction.
Sadguru Baba says, "I told you that the same man, Ramajiivana, is known as Rama to his father, as Ramu at work - and his children say `Babujii', and his students `Master Sahib'. and when he is moving along the street wearing a topii, the taungavala will say ,`Hey topii! Hey topii! Hey topii! He becomes a topii. But the man is that single man Rama." (1)
So here Baba is confirming the fact that one entity has multiple names. This is the common phenomenon. It is like that with nearly everyone. In different sphere of life, people have are referred to in various ways, using different names.
Singular Divine Personality has an infinite number of names
Who does not know that Parama Purus'a has an infinite number of names. He has so many names because He has an infinite number of attributions. Each attribution carries a different name.
Ananda Marga ideology states, "So Paramashiva, the Sadguru and Ta'raka Brahma are beyond the scope of the gun'atrikon'a... O Lord, Thou are the controller of everything, but there is nobody to control You. Your gun'as are beyond the scope of counting. Nobody can count how many gun'as are there. " (2)
Here above Baba is calling Lord Shiva three different names: Paramashiva, Sadguru, and Ta'raka Brahma. But He is not referring to three different Entities - rather One.
And about Lord Shiva we know there are so many more name plus others that we do not know. But at least there are two dozen well-known names of Lord Shiva: Pashupati, Nat’araja, Trilocana, Vya'gra'mbara, Painca'nana, Viireshvara, Mahadeva, Vaedyana'tha, Shiva, Maheshvara, Ma'ya'diisha, Niila Kan’t’ha, Ganga'dhara, Gaoriipati, Deveshvara, A'dipita', Mantresha, Maha’koala, Ta'raka Na'tha, Liila'dhara, Shaunkara, Kalabhairava, A’dinatha, A'shutos'a, Vajradhara, Hara, Shambhu, Vibhu'tinatha etc.
Here that point is that the more qualities and attributions one has, the more names one will be called. Because each name describes a different aspect of that same entity. And in the case of Parama Purusa who has an infinite number of attributions, He has an infinite number of names as well. Parama Purusa has countless gun'as (attributions) & hence so many names. All those names refer to Him, that one singular Parama Purusa.
The seer Padmadanta expressed this same idea
The great seer, poet and bhakta Padmadanta expressed this same idea. When bhaktas approached and asked him to write a poem about the Lord, then the seer Padmadanta replied that since the Lord has an infinite number of gunas (attributions). Only Parama Purusa knows all His characteristics and qualities.
Parama Purusa Baba has infinite qualities & infinite names
Baba is the Sadguru: He is one singular Divine Entity that has innumerable names: Baba, Parama Purusa, Taraka Brahma, Purusottoma, Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar, Mahasambhuti, Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji, and verily He has an infinite number of names. His countless names describe His infinite qualities. Yet, all those names refer to the same Divine Entity - Parama Purusa Baba.
So the whole idea is that Baba is Parama Purusa. He has an infinite number names to denote His infinite attributions. These names do not refer to different personalities. Parama Purusa Baba is one Entity with different names.
Conclusion
Ultimately then, the conclusion is easily reached that Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar and Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji are the same. These two names refer to the same Divine Personality.
Namaskar,
in Him,
Arjuna
~ In-depth study ~
Why His books are signed by different names
Some may still wonder why Parama Purusa Baba has used different names with authoring His books.
Here is the reply: Shrii Prabhat Ranjain Sarkar has been used for most of His books on social philosophy whereas Shrii Shrii Anandamurti has been used for most of His books on spiritual philosophy. And these two names refer to one Divine Entity.
Interestingly, some discourses like 'The Evolution of Society' appear in both social books like Prout and in spiritual books like Subhasita Samgraha. But who is going to say that two different entities gave that discourse. Absolutely no one. Because Baba is One Personality with multiple names and it is only He who has delivered that discourse.
And here are more of His discourses that were published under both names: 'Ahimsa', 'The Evolution of Society', 'Ananda Marga: A Revolution', 'Are Ghosts Hallucinations?', and so many others. All of these discourses appear in the Prout series or the A Few Problems Solved series which are signed as Shrii Prabhat Ranjain Sarkar yet are also published in books like Subhasita Samgraha, A Guide to Human Conduct, and Ananda Marga Philosophy in a Nutshell which are signed by Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji.
But again, the same singular Divine Entity wrote those discourses and His names Shrii Prabhat Ranjain Sarkar and Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji represent different aspects of His singular magnanimous personality.
Idea and Ideology by one Entity not two
All of the below listed discourses from the book Idea and Ideology have been published under both names: Shrii Prabhat Ranjain Sarkar and Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji. Because Idea and Ideology is published under the name Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar and those discourses also appear in the series Ananda Marga Philosophy in a Nutshell which is authored by Shrii Shrii Anandamurti.
Here then are a listing of those discourses that are published under both names: Shrii Prabhat Ranjain Sarkar and Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji.
Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar is for non-margiis
Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji is for margiis
We know that the name Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar is primarily for non-margiis and the name Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji is for Ananda Margiis.
Some Wts are terribly confused
You know there are a few Wts who always tells their story propagating that Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji and Shrii Prabhat Ranjain Sarkar are two separate entities.
References
1. Ananda Vacanamrtam, Part 3, His Reflections Are Everywhere
2. Ananda Vacanamrtam, part 3, 'Sadgurum Tvam Namami', p.46
Why sometimes Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji
and other times Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar
Namaskar,and other times Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar
Sometimes people wonder why some of our Ananda Marga books are authored under the name Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar whereas other books are signed as Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji. For years, people have been going back and forth about this, even questioning if these are two personalities or one.
Some want to know if both of these names refer to the same Divine Entity Baba. Here are some points related with this issue.
Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar & Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji: one & the same
Look at it this way, Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar and Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji certainly refer to one singular Entity.
For example, in the mundane sphere it is just like the situation of my mother. I call her mother; my sons and daughters call her grandmother or grandma; my cousin calls her aunty; and my father calls her Prama. And furthermore when she was working in the office she had her official designation also. Her colleagues were calling her yet a different name. In this manner, a single personality, my mother, has so many names - according to her relationship with a given person. So those names, i.e. mom, Prama, aunty, and grandma etc, do not refer to different personalities. Rather, she is one personality who has multiple names that apply to her various roles in life.
And verily this is the case with most people. According to particular situations they have a given name, yet all along they are the same person and personality.
Multiple names - one person
The following graphic example is moving in this same direction.
Sadguru Baba says, "I told you that the same man, Ramajiivana, is known as Rama to his father, as Ramu at work - and his children say `Babujii', and his students `Master Sahib'. and when he is moving along the street wearing a topii, the taungavala will say ,`Hey topii! Hey topii! Hey topii! He becomes a topii. But the man is that single man Rama." (1)
So here Baba is confirming the fact that one entity has multiple names. This is the common phenomenon. It is like that with nearly everyone. In different sphere of life, people have are referred to in various ways, using different names.
Singular Divine Personality has an infinite number of names
Who does not know that Parama Purus'a has an infinite number of names. He has so many names because He has an infinite number of attributions. Each attribution carries a different name.
Ananda Marga ideology states, "So Paramashiva, the Sadguru and Ta'raka Brahma are beyond the scope of the gun'atrikon'a... O Lord, Thou are the controller of everything, but there is nobody to control You. Your gun'as are beyond the scope of counting. Nobody can count how many gun'as are there. " (2)
Here above Baba is calling Lord Shiva three different names: Paramashiva, Sadguru, and Ta'raka Brahma. But He is not referring to three different Entities - rather One.
And about Lord Shiva we know there are so many more name plus others that we do not know. But at least there are two dozen well-known names of Lord Shiva: Pashupati, Nat’araja, Trilocana, Vya'gra'mbara, Painca'nana, Viireshvara, Mahadeva, Vaedyana'tha, Shiva, Maheshvara, Ma'ya'diisha, Niila Kan’t’ha, Ganga'dhara, Gaoriipati, Deveshvara, A'dipita', Mantresha, Maha’koala, Ta'raka Na'tha, Liila'dhara, Shaunkara, Kalabhairava, A’dinatha, A'shutos'a, Vajradhara, Hara, Shambhu, Vibhu'tinatha etc.
Here that point is that the more qualities and attributions one has, the more names one will be called. Because each name describes a different aspect of that same entity. And in the case of Parama Purusa who has an infinite number of attributions, He has an infinite number of names as well. Parama Purusa has countless gun'as (attributions) & hence so many names. All those names refer to Him, that one singular Parama Purusa.
The seer Padmadanta expressed this same idea
The great seer, poet and bhakta Padmadanta expressed this same idea. When bhaktas approached and asked him to write a poem about the Lord, then the seer Padmadanta replied that since the Lord has an infinite number of gunas (attributions). Only Parama Purusa knows all His characteristics and qualities.
Parama Purusa Baba has infinite qualities & infinite names
Baba is the Sadguru: He is one singular Divine Entity that has innumerable names: Baba, Parama Purusa, Taraka Brahma, Purusottoma, Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar, Mahasambhuti, Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji, and verily He has an infinite number of names. His countless names describe His infinite qualities. Yet, all those names refer to the same Divine Entity - Parama Purusa Baba.
So the whole idea is that Baba is Parama Purusa. He has an infinite number names to denote His infinite attributions. These names do not refer to different personalities. Parama Purusa Baba is one Entity with different names.
Conclusion
Ultimately then, the conclusion is easily reached that Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar and Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji are the same. These two names refer to the same Divine Personality.
Namaskar,
in Him,
Arjuna
~ In-depth study ~
Why His books are signed by different names
Some may still wonder why Parama Purusa Baba has used different names with authoring His books.
Here is the reply: Shrii Prabhat Ranjain Sarkar has been used for most of His books on social philosophy whereas Shrii Shrii Anandamurti has been used for most of His books on spiritual philosophy. And these two names refer to one Divine Entity.
Interestingly, some discourses like 'The Evolution of Society' appear in both social books like Prout and in spiritual books like Subhasita Samgraha. But who is going to say that two different entities gave that discourse. Absolutely no one. Because Baba is One Personality with multiple names and it is only He who has delivered that discourse.
And here are more of His discourses that were published under both names: 'Ahimsa', 'The Evolution of Society', 'Ananda Marga: A Revolution', 'Are Ghosts Hallucinations?', and so many others. All of these discourses appear in the Prout series or the A Few Problems Solved series which are signed as Shrii Prabhat Ranjain Sarkar yet are also published in books like Subhasita Samgraha, A Guide to Human Conduct, and Ananda Marga Philosophy in a Nutshell which are signed by Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji.
But again, the same singular Divine Entity wrote those discourses and His names Shrii Prabhat Ranjain Sarkar and Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji represent different aspects of His singular magnanimous personality.
Idea and Ideology by one Entity not two
All of the below listed discourses from the book Idea and Ideology have been published under both names: Shrii Prabhat Ranjain Sarkar and Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji. Because Idea and Ideology is published under the name Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar and those discourses also appear in the series Ananda Marga Philosophy in a Nutshell which is authored by Shrii Shrii Anandamurti.
Here then are a listing of those discourses that are published under both names: Shrii Prabhat Ranjain Sarkar and Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji.
1. Saiṋcara and PráńáhUnfortunately if you go to the Ananda Marga Publications website, they have wrongly listed Idea and Ideology as authored by Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji, but that is not correct. Baba has clearly published that book in the name Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar.
2. Pratisaiṋcara and Manah
3. Bhútatattva, Tanmátratattva and Indriyatattva
4. Mind, Práńendriya and Vrtti
5. Kośa
6. Átman, Paramátman and Sádhaná
7. Life, Death and Saḿskára
8. The Creation of the Universe
9. Psycho-Spiritual Parallelism
10. The Place of Sadvipras in the Samája Cakra
11. The Cosmic Brotherhood
Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar is for non-margiis
Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji is for margiis
We know that the name Shrii Prabhat Ranjan Sarkar is primarily for non-margiis and the name Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji is for Ananda Margiis.
Some Wts are terribly confused
You know there are a few Wts who always tells their story propagating that Shrii Shrii Anandamurti ji and Shrii Prabhat Ranjain Sarkar are two separate entities.
References
1. Ananda Vacanamrtam, Part 3, His Reflections Are Everywhere
2. Ananda Vacanamrtam, part 3, 'Sadgurum Tvam Namami', p.46
== Section 2 ==
তা না হ’লে, পারৰে সৰাই
“এই বারাণসী বা কাশী এখানে প্রতিষ্ঠিত হয়ে গেলে মনকে খুৰ দ্রুত উপরে তুলে ফেলতে হয় | এবং তন্ত্র সাধনা, কপাল সাধনা যা তোমাদের কেউ কেউ শিখেছ, এর ফলে মনে সেই দ্রুতি আসে, বেগ আসে | তখন এই যে বারাণসী তত্ত্ব এতে প্রতিষ্ঠিত হতে একটু সুবিধা হয় | তা না হ’লে, পারৰে সৰাই | কেন পারৰে না ? যে মানুষের শরীর পেয়েছে, সেই পারৰে | “ (1)
Unfortunately, the below English translation from the Electronic Edition of Baba's books (2009) is not up to the mark. It does not accurately portray Guru's original teaching given in Bengali featured above.
“To establish the mind on this point of Váráńasii or káshi, one has to quickly elevate the mind. Those who have learnt the technique of Tantra sádhaná or kápálika sádhaná, know what joy can be derived from this. It helps to establish the practitioner in the cult of Váráńasii. Those who have not yet mastered it, will one day be established in the cult of Váráńasii. Why not? Those who have acquired a human structure will surely be established in Váráńasii.]” (1)
References
1. Ananda Vacanamrtam - 7, Where Is Varanasi
हे मेरे परम प्रिय बाबा! यदि तुम मुझे सचमुच प्यार करते हो तो कृपा कर इस दीन की कुटिया में आओ ।
पीएस 2619 भालो वासो जदि ताबे ऐशो ...
हे मेरे परम प्रिय बाबा! यदि तुम मुझे सचमुच प्यार करते हो तो कृपा कर इस दीन की कुटिया में आओ । तुमको मैं अपने प्रेम गीत सुनाना चाहता हॅूं अपने हृदय की गहराई से; इसीलिये मैंने अपनी हृदयवीणा में अनेक स्वर और तानों का खूब अभ्यास कर रखा है।
बाबा!! मेरे पास किसी भी प्रकार का ज्ञान बुद्धि, सद्गुण या नाम ,यश कुछ भी नहीं है, केवल एक ही चीज है वह है अपने मन में तुमसे प्यार। मेरा पूरा हृदय तुम्हारे प्यार से भर गया है और तुम्हारी कृपा से उसे तुमको सौंपकर मैं तुम्हें संतुष्ठ कर दूंगा।
बाबा! मेरी कोई प्रतिष्ठा या सम्मान नहीं है, और न ही मेरे पास वह अभिमान है कि तुम्हारे न आने से मैं आहत होऊं। बाबा! मैं तो उसी से कृतकृत्य हॅूं जो चीजें तुमने मुझे कृपा पूर्वक दी हैं, अब तो केवल तुम अपनी अहेतुकी कृपा की वर्षा कर दो और आओ ।
बाबा! यदि सचमुच प्यार करते हो तो मेरे हृदय में और निकट आ जाओ। तुम्हारे लिये मैंने अपना मन गुरुचक्र में सजाकर तैयार कर रखा है कृपया निकट आकर कृतार्थ कीजिये।
- Trans: Dr. T.R.S
Note: If you would like the audio file of the above Prabhat Samgiita kindly write us.
Recent Postings
Other topics of interest
~ Legal Notice ~
“এই বারাণসী বা কাশী এখানে প্রতিষ্ঠিত হয়ে গেলে মনকে খুৰ দ্রুত উপরে তুলে ফেলতে হয় | এবং তন্ত্র সাধনা, কপাল সাধনা যা তোমাদের কেউ কেউ শিখেছ, এর ফলে মনে সেই দ্রুতি আসে, বেগ আসে | তখন এই যে বারাণসী তত্ত্ব এতে প্রতিষ্ঠিত হতে একটু সুবিধা হয় | তা না হ’লে, পারৰে সৰাই | কেন পারৰে না ? যে মানুষের শরীর পেয়েছে, সেই পারৰে | “ (1)
Unfortunately, the below English translation from the Electronic Edition of Baba's books (2009) is not up to the mark. It does not accurately portray Guru's original teaching given in Bengali featured above.
“To establish the mind on this point of Váráńasii or káshi, one has to quickly elevate the mind. Those who have learnt the technique of Tantra sádhaná or kápálika sádhaná, know what joy can be derived from this. It helps to establish the practitioner in the cult of Váráńasii. Those who have not yet mastered it, will one day be established in the cult of Váráńasii. Why not? Those who have acquired a human structure will surely be established in Váráńasii.]” (1)
References
1. Ananda Vacanamrtam - 7, Where Is Varanasi
== Section 3 ==
हे मेरे परम प्रिय बाबा! यदि तुम मुझे सचमुच प्यार करते हो तो कृपा कर इस दीन की कुटिया में आओ ।
पीएस 2619 भालो वासो जदि ताबे ऐशो ...
हे मेरे परम प्रिय बाबा! यदि तुम मुझे सचमुच प्यार करते हो तो कृपा कर इस दीन की कुटिया में आओ । तुमको मैं अपने प्रेम गीत सुनाना चाहता हॅूं अपने हृदय की गहराई से; इसीलिये मैंने अपनी हृदयवीणा में अनेक स्वर और तानों का खूब अभ्यास कर रखा है।
बाबा!! मेरे पास किसी भी प्रकार का ज्ञान बुद्धि, सद्गुण या नाम ,यश कुछ भी नहीं है, केवल एक ही चीज है वह है अपने मन में तुमसे प्यार। मेरा पूरा हृदय तुम्हारे प्यार से भर गया है और तुम्हारी कृपा से उसे तुमको सौंपकर मैं तुम्हें संतुष्ठ कर दूंगा।
बाबा! मेरी कोई प्रतिष्ठा या सम्मान नहीं है, और न ही मेरे पास वह अभिमान है कि तुम्हारे न आने से मैं आहत होऊं। बाबा! मैं तो उसी से कृतकृत्य हॅूं जो चीजें तुमने मुझे कृपा पूर्वक दी हैं, अब तो केवल तुम अपनी अहेतुकी कृपा की वर्षा कर दो और आओ ।
बाबा! यदि सचमुच प्यार करते हो तो मेरे हृदय में और निकट आ जाओ। तुम्हारे लिये मैंने अपना मन गुरुचक्र में सजाकर तैयार कर रखा है कृपया निकट आकर कृतार्थ कीजिये।
- Trans: Dr. T.R.S
Note: If you would like the audio file of the above Prabhat Samgiita kindly write us.
== Section 4: Links ==
Recent Postings
Other topics of interest
Reply to: anandamargauniversal1@
©2017 Ananda Marga Universal Forum. All rights reserved. Ananda Marga Universal Forum content is the intellectual property of Ananda Marga Universal Forum or its third party content providers. Ananda Marga Universal Forum shall not be liable for any errors or delays in content, or for any actions taken in reliance thereon. Any copying, republication or redistribution, part or full, of Ananda Marga Universal Forum content, including by framing or similar means, is against the court of law and expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Ananda Marga Universal Forum.
