~ AMPS News ~ #3 More Letters from Readers on MPD Dogma
Baba
Respected Readers,
This email contains 3 distinct sections featuring letters from margiis around the globe on this topic of MPD dogma.
1. From Amrit Lalloo to Tapeshvaranandji
2. From Devesh to Tapeshvaranandji
3. ...MPD is Black Spot on AM - by Panda
at His lotus feet,
Ananda Marga News Bulletin Moderators
Subject: Re: ~ AMPS News ~ #2 More Letters from Readers on MPD Dogma
Date: Wed, 30 Oct 2013 10:45:24 +0200
From: Amrit Lalloo <amr.....@gmail.com>
To: Ananda Marga News Bulletin
Namaskar.
MPD dogma lobbyists are bankrupt. Nothing meaningful or convincing spoken in support of MPD - only incoherent drivel.
They cannot be blamed for this - this maha-dogma just cannot be justified. It is impossible- and do you know why. There is no logic or rationale to support it. Over and above it is against Ananda Marga ideology and way of life.
Baba (Shrii Shrii Anandamurtii) is the subject of our devotional sentiment – our sadhana. If anyone believes that He is gone then there is no point in practicing Ananda Marga sadhana. Parama Purusa is attainable by unswerving devotion to Him alone.
The MPD lobbyists are clutching at straws or treading on rather dangerous turf.
Krsna said in Gita and Baba expanded and elaborated on it :
(Maya is very so powerful that it is insurmountable by human beings on their own. But it is My maya. Only those who surrender to Me can overcome this Maya.)
This is significant. MPD dogma is the product of Avidya Maya. Only those who surrender to Baba will surmount this maha-dogma.
“It is the ego that prevents one from telling the truth” - Baba
Amrit
Subject: Five days Kirtan of MPD should be shifted to Ananda Purnima
Date: Wed, 30 Oct 2013 21:58:21 +0530
From: Devesh Kumar <deveshkumarb.......mail.com>
To: Ananda Marga News Bulletin
Namaskar Tapeshvarananda Dada,
We are born to follow “Mahasambhuti Baba’s teachings” (Absolute Knowledge), Not “human teachings. Therefore, if Chandranath dada or any great WT have committed blunder and added chapter in Caryacarya after Baba’s physical departure, we are not here to follow their faulty instructions. We have to be very strict and follow “Non compromising strictness” to “ISTA and Adarsha”.
BABA Says,” "The period of mourning should not extend beyond twelve days." (CaryaCarya- part 1).
Therefore, there must not be any “Solemn observation” or any type of programme on 21st October (and 26th October). We have to follow only those festivals which are written by Baba in Caryacarya.
Five days kiirtan of Mahaprayan should be shifted to Ananda Purnima. Let everyone enjoy devotional five days kirtan on Ananda Purnima.
Baba says, "I keep no ambiguity, I am clear, concrete, conclusive. My philosophy is a complete philosophy, a complete way of life. I am complete in myself...I am like an arrow-- clear, pointed." (Supreme Expression).
Baba says, "You all know, where reasoning fails, vilification becomes the sole stock-in-trade. When you hear abuses from these frogs-in-the-well, you can take for granted that the grey matter in their frenzied brains has no functional residues left and that they have come to you only to convince you of their helpless and fey condition." (SS-part-3, chapter 'Shreya and Preya').
Note: A few WTs have abused me in emails. Above Baba’s teachings are for them.
Baba says, "Absolute knowledge is the direct message from God...The books in A'nanda Ma'rga philosophy are all absolute knowledge." (PNS-part 18, page.10).
At HIS Feet,
Devesh Kumar, Mumbai
Subject: Fw:
Date: Wed, 30 Oct 2013 14:28:45 +0800 (SGT)
From: narayan panda <tatnam......o.co.in>
To: Ananda Marga News Bulletin
Namaskar.
The purpose of writing about Bhaskarananda dadjii is so that margii brothers & sisters should not blindly believe in words of the great sanyasii brothers & sisters---"Baba told like this, like that......"
From Baba's delivered discourses on languages in books like Varna Vijinana, Varna Vicitra, Shabda Cayanika, we know that He gives importance to each & every language of the world. So it is irrational & illogical to support "original Bengali" business concept advocated by Tiljala group including Bhaskaranandajii.
I respect Bhaskaranandajii since he was much associated with my father-in-law, the late NRK Raju of Visakhapatnam & his family members. Dadaji's contribution towards Baba's mission is great. At the same time I can't agree with the meaningless policy of publication of Tiljala faction as described by Bhaskaranandajii as I didn't agree with my parents & relatives to follow so many illogical & irrational dogmatic customs, practices, advices after I came to know Baba's philosophy. But I have regards for them since they are elderly persons & they don't know the path of light of Ananda Marga. Similarly after Baba's physical departure we came to know the standard of so-called great sannyasii & gruhii dadas & diidiis. We have to discriminate the great dadas & diidiis with the help of the knowledge given by Baba.
Similarly when I could realise MPD a dogmatic function, my father-in-law still was following MPD. In year 1995 he read the letter against MPD circulated by Ganesh Bhat dada of Sirsi & Manjula diidii of Shimoga in Karantaka & he could realise his mistake & left MPD forever. Similarly A'c Harishankar of Ranchi stopped following MPD.
Like that, new margii brothers & sisters who came to know from me about the logic behind not to follow / observe MPD, expressed MPD is a black spot on Ananda Marga like shraddha function of prevailing religions which are opposed by Ananda Marga.
I agree with those who say that they get bliss from kiirttana performed in Tiljala from 21October to 26th October. But I oppose MPD which is the root cause of performance of kiirttana. The vaisnava followers also get bliss from Hare rama hare krisna kiirtana conducted on occasion of death day of their gurus. As per Ananda Marga philosophy observance of death day is dogmatic. Therefore I compare the followers of Ananda Marga (who attend / observe MPD) with these vaisnavas.
Nara'yan'a
Namaskar.
I am surprised. I generated great respect and love to Dada Bhaskarananda when I learnt "Glimpses of Mystery" but it just came to zero when I learnt letters of respected Pandaji.
In a similar way "Living with Baba" provided me a lot of honor and love to Dada Tapeshvarananda which I personally expressed him through his mail address and he too responded but, this mail has lessened it considerably.
I am unable to understand why such learned and senior dadas who have been so contiguous to Rev. Baba have lost their mind on such an irrational matter of MPD which is completely against Baba's teachings.
Yours,
Dr T.R. Sukul
Baba
Respected Readers,
This email contains 3 distinct sections featuring letters from margiis around the globe on this topic of MPD dogma.
1. From Amrit Lalloo to Tapeshvaranandji
2. From Devesh to Tapeshvaranandji
3. ...MPD is Black Spot on AM - by Panda
at His lotus feet,
Ananda Marga News Bulletin Moderators
Subject: Re: ~ AMPS News ~ #2 More Letters from Readers on MPD Dogma
Date: Wed, 30 Oct 2013 10:45:24 +0200
From: Amrit Lalloo <amr.....@gmail.com>
To: Ananda Marga News Bulletin
FROM A. LALLOO TO DADA TAPESHVARANANDJI
Namaskar.
MPD dogma lobbyists are bankrupt. Nothing meaningful or convincing spoken in support of MPD - only incoherent drivel.
They cannot be blamed for this - this maha-dogma just cannot be justified. It is impossible- and do you know why. There is no logic or rationale to support it. Over and above it is against Ananda Marga ideology and way of life.
Baba (Shrii Shrii Anandamurtii) is the subject of our devotional sentiment – our sadhana. If anyone believes that He is gone then there is no point in practicing Ananda Marga sadhana. Parama Purusa is attainable by unswerving devotion to Him alone.
The MPD lobbyists are clutching at straws or treading on rather dangerous turf.
Krsna said in Gita and Baba expanded and elaborated on it :
(Maya is very so powerful that it is insurmountable by human beings on their own. But it is My maya. Only those who surrender to Me can overcome this Maya.)
This is significant. MPD dogma is the product of Avidya Maya. Only those who surrender to Baba will surmount this maha-dogma.
“It is the ego that prevents one from telling the truth” - Baba
Amrit
======
Subject: Five days Kirtan of MPD should be shifted to Ananda Purnima
Date: Wed, 30 Oct 2013 21:58:21 +0530
From: Devesh Kumar <deveshkumarb.......mail.com>
To: Ananda Marga News Bulletin
FROM DEVESH TO DADA TAPESHVARANANDJI
Namaskar Tapeshvarananda Dada,
We are born to follow “Mahasambhuti Baba’s teachings” (Absolute Knowledge), Not “human teachings. Therefore, if Chandranath dada or any great WT have committed blunder and added chapter in Caryacarya after Baba’s physical departure, we are not here to follow their faulty instructions. We have to be very strict and follow “Non compromising strictness” to “ISTA and Adarsha”.
BABA Says,” "The period of mourning should not extend beyond twelve days." (CaryaCarya- part 1).
Therefore, there must not be any “Solemn observation” or any type of programme on 21st October (and 26th October). We have to follow only those festivals which are written by Baba in Caryacarya.
Five days kiirtan of Mahaprayan should be shifted to Ananda Purnima. Let everyone enjoy devotional five days kirtan on Ananda Purnima.
Baba says, "I keep no ambiguity, I am clear, concrete, conclusive. My philosophy is a complete philosophy, a complete way of life. I am complete in myself...I am like an arrow-- clear, pointed." (Supreme Expression).
Baba says, "You all know, where reasoning fails, vilification becomes the sole stock-in-trade. When you hear abuses from these frogs-in-the-well, you can take for granted that the grey matter in their frenzied brains has no functional residues left and that they have come to you only to convince you of their helpless and fey condition." (SS-part-3, chapter 'Shreya and Preya').
Note: A few WTs have abused me in emails. Above Baba’s teachings are for them.
Baba says, "Absolute knowledge is the direct message from God...The books in A'nanda Ma'rga philosophy are all absolute knowledge." (PNS-part 18, page.10).
At HIS Feet,
Devesh Kumar, Mumbai
======
Subject: Fw:
Date: Wed, 30 Oct 2013 14:28:45 +0800 (SGT)
From: narayan panda <tatnam......o.co.in>
To: Ananda Marga News Bulletin
RE: TAPESHVARANANDJI LOST HIS MIND
MPD IS A BLACK SPOT ON AM
LIKE SHRADDHA FUNCTION OF PREVAILING RELIGIONS
MPD IS A BLACK SPOT ON AM
LIKE SHRADDHA FUNCTION OF PREVAILING RELIGIONS
Namaskar.
The purpose of writing about Bhaskarananda dadjii is so that margii brothers & sisters should not blindly believe in words of the great sanyasii brothers & sisters---"Baba told like this, like that......"
From Baba's delivered discourses on languages in books like Varna Vijinana, Varna Vicitra, Shabda Cayanika, we know that He gives importance to each & every language of the world. So it is irrational & illogical to support "original Bengali" business concept advocated by Tiljala group including Bhaskaranandajii.
I respect Bhaskaranandajii since he was much associated with my father-in-law, the late NRK Raju of Visakhapatnam & his family members. Dadaji's contribution towards Baba's mission is great. At the same time I can't agree with the meaningless policy of publication of Tiljala faction as described by Bhaskaranandajii as I didn't agree with my parents & relatives to follow so many illogical & irrational dogmatic customs, practices, advices after I came to know Baba's philosophy. But I have regards for them since they are elderly persons & they don't know the path of light of Ananda Marga. Similarly after Baba's physical departure we came to know the standard of so-called great sannyasii & gruhii dadas & diidiis. We have to discriminate the great dadas & diidiis with the help of the knowledge given by Baba.
Similarly when I could realise MPD a dogmatic function, my father-in-law still was following MPD. In year 1995 he read the letter against MPD circulated by Ganesh Bhat dada of Sirsi & Manjula diidii of Shimoga in Karantaka & he could realise his mistake & left MPD forever. Similarly A'c Harishankar of Ranchi stopped following MPD.
Like that, new margii brothers & sisters who came to know from me about the logic behind not to follow / observe MPD, expressed MPD is a black spot on Ananda Marga like shraddha function of prevailing religions which are opposed by Ananda Marga.
I agree with those who say that they get bliss from kiirttana performed in Tiljala from 21October to 26th October. But I oppose MPD which is the root cause of performance of kiirttana. The vaisnava followers also get bliss from Hare rama hare krisna kiirtana conducted on occasion of death day of their gurus. As per Ananda Marga philosophy observance of death day is dogmatic. Therefore I compare the followers of Ananda Marga (who attend / observe MPD) with these vaisnavas.
Nara'yan'a
Following is Sukulji's earlier letter that inspired the above reply...
Namaskar.
I am surprised. I generated great respect and love to Dada Bhaskarananda when I learnt "Glimpses of Mystery" but it just came to zero when I learnt letters of respected Pandaji.
In a similar way "Living with Baba" provided me a lot of honor and love to Dada Tapeshvarananda which I personally expressed him through his mail address and he too responded but, this mail has lessened it considerably.
I am unable to understand why such learned and senior dadas who have been so contiguous to Rev. Baba have lost their mind on such an irrational matter of MPD which is completely against Baba's teachings.
Yours,
Dr T.R. Sukul
