REPLY TO TAPESHESHVARANANDJI ON EX-WT & TRAITOR & MORE
Baba
Respected Readers,
This email contains 3 distinct sections featuring letters from margiis around the globe:
1. Sarvatmananda & Tapeshvarananda Were Both Traitors by Pranav
2. Chandranath Dada Was Also Against Mahaprayan by Devesh
3. Chandranath Dada Was Also Against Mahaprayan by Kamalesh
at His lotus feet,
Ananda Marga News Bulletin Moderators
====
Date: Thu, 31 Oct 2013 08:16:29
Subject: Sarvatmananda & Tapeshvarananda Were Both Traitors
From: Pranav Ghosh
To: Ananda Marga News Bulletin
SARVATMANANDA AND TAPESHVARANANDA WERE BOTH TRAITORS
Namaskar,
Here I raise two matters for consideration:
[A] In his letter, respected Dada Tapeshvaranandji makes this statement:
"those are not able to do WT life or ex -WT only they oppose [mahaprayan]."
So Dadaji claims that those who are ex-Wts hate MPD, but in my practical experience I see the opposite happening. Let us not forget that from the main line of AMPS, not less than 50 Wts were expelled and they became the Kolkata faction or Tiljala group etc. One of those expelled was Tapeshvaranandji himself, along with 50 more. Yet all such expelled or ex-Wts are themselves strict followers and die-hard proponents of MPD.
[B] In his letter, respected Dada Tapeshvaranandji makes this statement:
"Now Those are indisciplined and betrayed Baba."
So although Dadaji makes such a statement, let us not forget that Sarvatmanandji was himself living with and amongst that traitor group. Sarvatmanandji was away from Baba in the opposite campt. It is just Baba's causeless grace that Sarvatmanandji was arrested in Motihari case by CBI and had no way to join defectors group. Save for that he was a member of those defectors as we must not forget that he was away 1 month with traitor group before that time.
Then in his own story book, Dada Tapeshvaranandji describes about so-called 7 Tests and that Dada Tapeshvaranandji himself went with traitors for 7 days. Means Tapeshvaranandji was in opposite camp of Baba, and then Baba graciously called him and saved him from his fate. Initially Tapeshvarananda Dada recounted how he did not want to go back but eventually he conceded and returned back. This is the actual history which Tapeshvaranandji himself recounts in his own publication.
Having considered the above two points, it seems that Dadaji is referencing his own greatness in both of the above two allegations.
In Him,
Pranav Ghosh
====
Subject: Chandranath Dada Was Also Against Mahaprayan
Date: Thu, 31 Oct 2013 13:01:03 +0530
From: Devesh Kumar <deveshkuma.......com>
To: Ananda Marga News Bulletin
CHANDRANATH DADA WAS ALSO AGAINST MAHAPRAYAN
Namaskar,
Chandranath dada was a great soul. No doubt at all. Just now many margiis informed me - in the beginning in 1991 or 1992, one meeting was held in Patna regarding mahaprayan. Respected Chandranath dada and many margiis were present. All margis unanimously decided to protest against mahaprayan. However, afterwards some top level WTs, who are now leading Kolkata group and Ranchi group, took benefit of simplicity of Chandranath dada. He was always against mahaprayan observation.
Mahaprayan supporters always write that mahaprayan was decided in Central Committee meeting. Therefore, fate of mahaprayan can only be decided in CC meeting.
Here one question arises - Whether “Creating parallel AMPS in 2003” was also decided in Central Committee meeting? Without Central committee meeting why two AMPS was created? Is it not against Caryacarya? Is it not Gurudroha?
Baba wrote in Caryacaraya - Baba says, "The unity of A'nanda Ma'rgiis should not be allowed to be jeopardised for any reason. Unity should be maintained even at the risk of your life." (CC, part II, 'Society' chapter, point #13)
Everybody knows that parallel AMPS were established against Caryacarya in 2003. Some top level WTs has spoiled AMPS. They are free to create parallel AMPS without CC meeting, but they want CC meeting for Mahaprayan. It is called hypocrisy.
At HIS FEET,
Devesh Kumar, Mumbai
====
Subject: Chandranath Dada Was Also Against Mahaprayan
Date: Thu, 31 Oct 2013 14:37:26
From: kamalesh.yadav
To: Ananda Marga News Bulletin
FROM KAMALESH YADAV
Baba
Namaskar,
Regarding Shrii Candranath, Dada Tapeshvaranandji makes the following statement:
"The word Mahaprayan was approved and introduced by Ac Candranathji, Who was the President of Central Committee."
Ac Candranathji was under pressure and at CC meeting he did not oppose that is why it is said it was unanimously approved, but he did not like it and he did so only under pressure.
In the name of unity many simple margiis did not oppose. I too was present.
In Him,
Kamalesh
